Stefano's Italian of Florence

Queen D

3 out of 5 stars★★★☆☆

Nice and helpful staff. I ordered the 10 inch Italian sub and onion rings. The onion rings were decent but greasy but the sauce that came with it was delicious! The sub was a good price point but subpar, small, and did not come seasoned or with lettuce as advertised. Seasoning and lettuce would have made it a ton better. May go back to try a pizza . Bring cash to save 4%

Kia Kaiser

3 out of 5 stars★★★☆☆

I used to love coming to Stefano’s, but my most recent order was pretty lackluster to say the least. If you’ve ever ordered pizza from Stefano’s, you know they are usually big with plenty of toppings for a premium price. This is what I also expected when I ordered the GF pizza tonight, and it couldn’t be more the opposite. The pizza was like a personal pan pizza with 6 small slices and minimal toppings, no bigger than a 16oz bottle of soda. I would have been okay with this if it was disclosed prior to ordering. I first called them to ask about the GF crust, which they could have disclosed the info about the size then; and it was no where on the website when ordering online about the size being so small. If I had know about the size, I would not have paid $24 for it. I was not offered any remedy or refund when picking up, so my only option was to take the pizza and take the L with it. Their website and online ordering experience needs significant improvements and updates as well.

Wayne Grantham

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

An Absolutely Perfect Lunch at Stefano’s Stopped in for lunch at Stefano’s and wow — this place knocked it out of the park. The Meatball Sub "Grinder" in the photo says it all: fresh, toasted bread, generous portions, rich homemade sauce, perfectly melted cheese, and that classic Italian comfort-food vibe you just don’t get from chain restaurants. Every bite tasted like it was made with care and quality ingredients. The balance of flavors was spot-on, and the portion size was more than satisfying for a lunchtime meal. You can tell this is a locally owned spot that takes pride in what they serve. If you’re looking for authentic, delicious Italian food with that “made-from-scratch” feel, Stefano’s is a must-visit. This was hands-down one of the best lunches I’ve had in a long time. Highly recommend — and I’ll definitely be back! 👏🍝🥪

Cory Minnich

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

11 of us had dinner there. The only food that was not top-notch was the pre-diced chicken in 4 of the make-your-own pasta dishes. It tasted as though it had been cut days ago and frozen. Several others had chicken as an entree or on salads and that was all excellent! Don't miss out ... If you want to try the best homemade mozzarella sticks....this is the place. Sorry no pictures.. only because all 8 disappeared faster than I could get my camera out. Highly recommend! On the entree side, Eggplant parmesan was great. Lemon grilled chicken was excellent as was a MYO pasta with shrimp. The marinara and the vodka sauces were definitely the stars of the show. Marinara was bright red and had magnificent flavor. The vodka sauce was some of the heartiest I have tasted with a very complex flavor profile. The portions were plenty large. The servers were excellent! Definitely check this place out.